« Otter chaos and High Mass Destruction | Main | Greek Fire or Geek Ire ? »

September 27, 2006

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451b13569e200d83460f0d869e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Blast From The Past:

» An Inconvenient Comparison from A Short Course in Chaos
Many are probably aware of Al Gore\'s movie about global warming, An Inconvenient Truth. In all fairness, I\'ve not seen it yet, but I\'ve read a moderate number of the arguments on either side of global warming. I\'ve also been a student in a highly t... [Read More]

Comments

Randy Eischer, Jr.

I'm feeling a lot of heat radiating from this article but not much light. A few dozen nuclear strikes launched across the globe over a week or so would surely kick up quite a bit of dust and smoke, but are you saying that this problem would be negligible, a mere inconvenience?

I don't see much in the way of any data--how much matter would be injected into the stratosphere and for how long if, say, the top twenty cities in the world were attacked? Top fifty? Would a thick layer of ash settle on everything like after Mount St. Helens, or would that, too, be negligible? Would crops have a hard time growing, would it be chilly at all, would we have to start guzzling a lot of salt laced with iodine?

The article simply read like an angry "Is not!" hurled at a perceived "Is too!"
RESPONSE

Please study at the graphs and read what I wrote in _Nature_, _Foreign Affairs _and _The National Interest _.

The 'nuclear winter ' model authors arbitrarily and incorrectly assumed hundreds of millions of tons of dust and soot forming an opaque pall lasting many months and producing tens of thousands of degree= days of cooling globally. Three years of parameter studied eliminated the dust as significant factor- it fell or rained out in days to weeks, and cut the smoke ad soot budget bt an order of magnitude. The result was not a global deep freeze but single digit cooling totaling hundreds of degree days- it's the difference between 'winter' in Siberia and Florida.

The before and after scenarios in both generations of models included the major cities you mention.

Read the three volume SCOPE- ENUWAR report for a handle on the details.

Health News

This is a wonderful site. The things mentioned are unanimous and needs to be appreciated by everyone.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

.. .. Russell Seitz .. ..

  • search results
  • Consulting Services



  •  
    View blog reactions

  • Locations of visitors to this page

Lampreys , Lemmings , and Loons

The Last Post And Chorus